Your search results

Contact Castaways Island Realty for your property needs.

Castaways Island Realty & Rentals can help you land your island dream, whether you’re looking to buy, sell, or rent, you’ve come to the right place!

 NO ONE knows the island better than the team at Castaways. Many of us are lifelong residents who live, work, and play here and we are personally invested in the Pine Island community.

Land Your Dream Home

The Island Lifestyle

Castaways Island Realty


Nestled between the mainland of Southwest Florida and the islands of Sanibel and Captiva is a 17-mile-long island accessible by a single drawbridge. Pine Island has three distinct areas, each with unique character and charm, but all a rare and lingering remnant of Old Florida. Learn more…

Neil is outstanding to work with Asia the staff. Extremely helpful.
Harry Albaugh


Little Slice of Paradise

Upon impending retirement, my husband decided to shop for a home on Pine Island. We were put in touch with Staci Stevens. She was very engaged from the beginning, asking pertinent questions about our priorities and also giving us a wealth of information about options that quite frankly we never would have thought to ask. She showed us many properties both via facetime walkthroughs, personally narrated by her, and also physically on site. She always returned our many calls promptly and professionally and eventually led us to purchase our own "little slice of paradise."
Lorri D
Home Buyer

Living Our Dream

We were looking for our dream home in Southwest Florida and knew we wanted someone who knew this area inside and out. Staci was amazing to work with! She answered all our questions, booked every home tour that fit our needs and negotiated a great deal for us. As first-time home buyers, we were completely lost on how this process works and thankfully had Staci to guide us along the way. We are now living our dream in paradise thanks to Staci Stevens!
Chris F
Home Buyer
Based on 5 reviews
Jeffrey Kling
Great rental properties and services
Harry Albaugh
Neil is outstanding to work with Asia the staff. Extremely helpful.
Virgie Komp
They really know the local area and are every good at recommendations from contractors and especially helpful at the time of a sale
ken fries
Peter “PJ” Hertel

Compare Listings